By Myra Adams – The Hill contributor
MYRA’S COMPLETE ARCHIVE IS HERE
Reposted from The Hill: Nov. 13, 2026

A strong historical trend in presidential elections suggests that Democrats will win the White House in 2028. Let’s call it the “open seat phenomenon.” An open seat occurs when an incumbent president does not seek another term, either by law or by choice.
Since World War II, there have been eight open-seat presidential elections. The incumbent president’s party has lost seven of them. Only the Republican victory in 1988 interrupted the trend.
Can those winning circumstances from 40 years ago apply to the Republicans in their 2028 open-seat race?
In 1952, the White House shifted from Democrat to Republican. This came after President Harry S. Truman announced that he would not seek a full second term. The previous month, his job approval rating had fallen to 22 percent. He had already served nearly eight years, beginning on April 12, 1945, after President Franklin D. Roosevelt’s death. Truman governed through many of the 20th century’s most tumultuous years. But then Republicans won in a landslide, electing World War II hero General Dwight D. Eisenhower.
In 1960, the presidency went back to the Democrats. After Eisenhower’s two terms, Sen. John F. Kennedy (D-Mass.) defeated incumbent Vice President Richard Nixon (R). At 43, Kennedy embodied youthful optimism, a commitment to national service, and leadership for the new decade.
Then, in 1968, Kennedy’s successor President Lyndon Johnson declined to run a second full term amid growing unpopularity over the raging Vietnam War. Consequently, former Vice President Richard Nixon defeated Johnson’s Vice President, Hubert Humphrey (D).
The exceptional year was 1988. After two landslide victories in 1980 and 1984, President Ronald Reagan’s job approval averaged 53 percent in the months before Election Day. His popularity, coupled with a robust economy, propelled Vice President George H.W. Bush to win Reagan’s “third term” with 53 percent of the vote. Bush won the Electoral College with 426 votes — the last president to receive more than 400.
The next open presidential election took place in 2000. President Bill Clinton (D) was term-limited and remained popular despite having been impeached in 1998. Nonetheless, his vice president, Al Gore (D), lost to Texas Gov. George W. Bush (R) in a controversial election in which Gore won the national popular vote. After a five-to-four Supreme Court decision, the Florida recount was halted. Bush won Florida by only 537 votes and was awarded the state’s 25 Electoral College votes, bringing his total to 271 — just enough for the presidency.
In 2008, the younger President Bush was quite unpopular, as the “Great Recession” had begun and the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan were continuing. The Republican nominee, Sen. John McCain (R-Ariz.), was no match for Illinois Sen. Barack Obama, who promised “hope and change.” Obama won decisively, ending the Bush era and celebrated as the nation’s first African American president.
Then in 2016, after President Obama’s two terms, Republicans won with President Trump, a celebrity businessman with no political experience. In a shocking upset, Trump defeated Hillary Clinton (D), a former U.S. senator, first lady, and secretary of State. Although Trump won the Electoral College, Clinton won the popular vote.
Then, in 2024, incumbent President Joe Biden appeared on track to lose reelection. Democratic leaders all but forced him to withdraw just 107 days before Election Day, triggering an open-seat election. Vice President Kamala Harris (D) was quickly nominated, but Trump defeated her, capitalizing on the nation’s dour mood and Biden’s unpopularity. Trump’s victory marked a historic comeback after his 2020 loss.
So what about 2028? The incumbent president’s party has lost seven of the eight open-seat presidential elections over seven decades. So what caused Reagan’s vice president to buck the losing trend in 1988?
If Republicans are to win Trump’s “third term,” they must satisfy two criteria and receive a gift from Democrats.
First, Trump must boost his job approval rating above 50 percent. It is currently in the dumps at 38 percent on average.
Second, Bush ran on continuing Reagan’s successful economic policies. In 1988, GDP growth was nearly 4.2 percent. By comparison, 2026 GDP growth is a paltry 1.7 percent, down from 2025.
Most importantly, Trump will have to resolve the affordability crisis, partially tied to his own tariffs and the unpopular Iran war. Only then will voters support a Republican nominee who pledges to continue the president’s policies.
If not, 2028 hopefuls — some quietly, some openly — will distance themselves from Trump. They will seek to forge a new Republican era as a chaotic rebirth sparks intra-party warfare and angers the mercurial incumbent.
But don’t discount Democrats gifting Republicans a weak, out-of-touch liberal nominee. That was key to 1988, when they nominated Massachusetts Gov. Mike Dukakis (D). Even so, Republicans will face a tough election cycle and probably lose, unless Trump’s job approval and economic conditions improve significantly.
Myra Adams served on the creative team of two Republican presidential campaigns in 2004 and 2008. Read more from her archive at The Hill.









